I called my momma, she was out for a walk
Consoled a cup of coffee, but it didn't wanna talk
So I picked up a paper, it was more bad news
More hearts being broken or people being used
I apologize in advance for this long entry but I actually have a specific topic in mind for this blog! (I know, imagine that.)
So I think I mentioned my Documentary Film class to you guys before. The professor is pretty intense, and sometimes I wish I had switched out of the class. However, this week I found the topic we were working on very interesting. We’re doing a Crime and Punishment section and watched the films Capturing the Friedmans and Dear Zachary. Both films show very different sides of the American justice system, and have led me to wonder whether we are running our judicial system correctly.
---
Capturing the Friedmans is a pretty disturbing film about a family immersed in a sex scandal. Arnold Friedman (the father) and Jesse Friedman (one of his three sons) are accused of child molestation. The father ran computer classes out of his house, and this is where the alleged sexual acts occurred. While this topic is disturbing in and of itself, the way this case was handled was even more disturbing.
Both men insisted they were innocent throughout the entire ordeal. What was odd about this case was that there was no physical evidence to support what had happened. The computer classes had been running for several years, and yet none of the children had ever confessed to their parents what had happened. In fact, the only reason this case surfaced was because mail services found child pornography being sent to Arnold Friedman. That's when the childrens' stories began to come out.

(Arnold and Jesse Friedman)
The case was entirely based on the testimonies from these students which were circumspect at best. Some students denied anything ever happened in those computer classes. Some who believe they were molested only recalled what happened after being hypnotized!
While the family was extremely weird and Arnold Friedman later confessed to child molestation (although in a completely different occurrence), I find what happened here somewhat alarming. Both men were convicted without a shred of evidence against them! (Besides the circumspect testimonies.) I'm not saying that these men didn't commit these crimes, but I don't think there was enough evidence to convict them either.
The full movie can be viewed on Youtube.
---
Dear Zachary is about film about Andrew Bagby, a doctor who was killed by his ex-girlfriend, Shirley Turner. She later announces she is pregnant with his son, Zachary. One of Andrew’s friends, a documentary filmmaker, travels across the country collecting stories about Andrew’s life so that Zachary can learn about who his father was.

(Andrew Bagby)
The film also follows the trial of Shirley Turner. The case is drawn out over several months, and Shirley was never officially charged with this crime. We also see the struggle of Andrew’s parents (Zachary’s grandparents) as they fight Shirley for custody/visitation rights of Zachary - basically the cutest baby you’ve ever seen. They move to Newfoundland in order to be closer to their grandson and have to deal with Shirley, the woman who murdered their son, every day. The Bagbys are pretty amazing people.

(Kate and David Bagby with Zachary Turner)
First of all, let me just say that this film was PHENOMENAL. It really knocked me off my feet. It is so rare to find a film that portrays such raw human emotion. I swear, if I hadn’t been in class at the time I would have been bawling my eyes out. You feel the devastation and rage of this family as if you had experienced their loss for yourself.
I won’t tell you what happens in the end, because I really think you should see this film. Be forewarned, it is an extremely sad story. The havoc that Shirley Turner reeks on the lives of the Bagbys is truly heartbreaking.
What I can’t understand in this situation is why Shirley wasn’t charged with this crime! All the evidence pointed to her! She had driven over 10 hours to see Andrew that day despite the fact that he had broken up with her. Her SUV was spotted at the scene of the crime. The bullets found at the scene matched those in Shirley’s gun - a gun she had just bought! She had a history of mental illness, and several restraining orders put against her. And yet the judge ruled that she was not a danger to the community and she was let out on bail. --- If you see this movie, you will realize what a terrible mistake that judge made. Everything that happened next could have been prevented.
The full movie can be viewed here and here (part 2).
---
When you compare what happened to the Friedmans and how Turner was treated, it really seems like our judicial system has failed. How can two people be convicted when no evidence condemns them, while a woman who is so obviously guilty is set free?
Let’s look at another recent case - Amanda Knox and the murder of Meredith Kercher. Both girls were students studying abroad in Italy and shared an apartment. Meredith was found dead in her room with several stab wounds and evidence of sexual assault. Amanda Knox (and two others) was found guilty and sentenced to 26 years in prison.

(Amanda Knox)
This case is extremely controversial right now. In Italy, you are guilty until proven innocent (in America we believe the opposite). No evidence seems to even point to Amanda Knox. She admits that she was abused during the 53 HOURS she was being questioned by police. Her DNA was not found in the room where Meredith was murdered (another man’s was, he was also convicted). This case is so disturbing to me because Amanda Knox was just about my age when this happened to her! I plan to study abroad in my junior year as well. I cannot imagine something like this happening to me.
These cases bring up several controversial questions about the way judicial systems work. Should criminals be innocent until proven guilty, or vice versa? Judicial systems are designed to protect the rights of the defendants as well as the accused - but should the people convicted of such heinous crimes have rights?
I’m not sure how I feel about this. I think everyone should have the right to a fair trial but evidence is CRUCIAL in convicting someone. Remember that people should be found guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt.” There should be no doubt that the accused is guilty! In the case of the Friedmans and Amanda Knox, I believe there wasn’t enough evidence. Shirley Turner should have been rotting in prison for the rest of her life.
I don’t know... This is such a difficult topic, and I feel like I have so much to say about it. But more importantly - what do you think? If anyone actually bothered to read through this diatribe, I’d really be interested in hearing your opinion.
Anyway, these last couple of days have been crazy busy and I haven’t gotten much sleep so I’m turning in early tonight. Talk to you soon!
Love,
Kristen